Skip to content

Read a verification result

What the verdict, the recommendation, the score and the reason of a PricklyMails result mean, and what to do with each address before you send.

Every address you verify comes back with four answers: a recommendation, a verdict, a score from 0 to 100, and a reason. You see them in the result of a verification, in its Verification detail panel, and in the report of a batch. The recommendation says what to do; the other three say why.

The recommendation: what to do

Start with the recommendation: it turns the result into one of three actions.

The three recommendations, and what to do with each address
RecommendationWhat it meansWhat to do
SendThe mailbox can receive email: its server confirmed it, or the address is at Outlook or Yahoo, which confirm no mailbox to anyone.Send normally.
ReviewNothing proves the address is bad, and nothing confirms it: a generic address, a domain that accepts any address, or a server with no clear answer.Decide with the reason, as shown below.
RemoveThe address cannot receive email, is disposable, or holds a typo.Take it out of your list before you send.

The verdict: what the checks found

The verdict states what the checks established about the address.

The four verdicts
VerdictWhat it means
ValidThe address can receive email.
RiskyA check raised a flag: a disposable or generic address, a domain that accepts any address, a parked domain, or a mailbox that was not checked.
InvalidThe address cannot receive email: it is malformed, its domain has no working mail server, or the server said the mailbox does not exist.
Not verifiableThe mail server gave no clear answer in time, or refused to be asked. The checks left without an answer are refunded.

The verdict and the recommendation usually agree, with three deliberate exceptions:

  • An address at Outlook or Yahoo comes back Valid and Send, with the reason Major provider, mailbox not confirmable and a capped score: these providers never say whether a mailbox exists, so no one can confirm it.
  • A disposable address, or an address on a parked domain, comes back Risky but Remove: it may accept email, but it is meant to be abandoned, or sits on a domain for sale or idle.
  • An address whose domain looks mistyped comes back Remove whatever its verdict, with a suggested correction: jane@gmial.com suggests jane@gmail.com.

Warning

Check a suggested correction before you swap it in: it shows what the person probably meant to type, not what they typed.

The score

The score, from 0 to 100, says how confident the result is that the address will receive your email. A mailbox its server accepted scores up to 88 without the catch-all check, and up to 96 when that check ran and ruled out a domain that accepts any address. An address at Outlook or Yahoo stays below a confirmed mailbox, since nothing was confirmed.

Sort on the recommendation first, and use the score for stricter rules of your own, for example before a cold outreach campaign.

The reason

Each result names one reason in plain words, and the Cause line below it explains that reason in one sentence.

What each reason means, and the recommendation it leads to
ReasonRecommendationWhat happened
Mailbox exists SendThe domain's mail server confirmed that this mailbox exists.
Major provider, mailbox not confirmable SendThe domain's email is hosted by Microsoft or Yahoo, which answer every check the same way.
Malformed address RemoveThe address does not follow the format of an email address, so no server can receive it.
Domain does not receive email RemoveThe domain declares no mail server.
Domain refuses all email RemoveThe domain states explicitly that it accepts no email.
Mail servers do not exist RemoveThe domain names mail servers, but none of them can be reached, so no email can arrive.
Parked domain, not in use RemoveThe domain is for sale or idle, with no real mailbox.
Mailbox does not exist RemoveThe domain's mail server answered that this mailbox does not exist.
Disposable address RemoveThe domain belongs to a disposable address service, whose addresses are meant to be used once and abandoned.
Disposable email service RemoveThe domain's email goes through the mail servers of a disposable address service.
Generic address ReviewThe address names a role, such as contact@ or info@, rather than a person.
Domain accepts any address ReviewThe mail server accepts any address, even an invented one, so it cannot confirm this one.
Mailbox full ReviewThe mailbox exists, but cannot receive email right now.
Mailbox not checked ReviewThe mailbox check did not run, so only the address and its domain were checked.
No answer in time ReviewThe mail server did not answer within the time allowed.
Server asked to retry later ReviewThe mail server asked to try again later, and the check could not finish.
Server unavailable ReviewThe mail server was temporarily unavailable.
Mail server unreachable ReviewNo connection could be opened with the domain's mail servers.
Too many checks on this domain right now ReviewThe limit of checks on this domain's mail servers was reached, so the mailbox was not checked this time.
Provider refuses checks ReviewThe provider refuses this kind of check before the mailbox can be asked, as GMX, web.de, and IONOS do.
Unknown error ReviewThe check stopped on an unexpected error before it reached an answer.

Developers find the same fields in the API, described in Verify an email.

What to do with an address to review

A Review does not mean the address is bad: it means a human decision beats an automatic rule.

  • Generic address: keep it if the company knows you, and leave it out of a cold outreach campaign.
  • Domain accepts any address: send to a small group first and watch the bounces; Catch-all domains explains why the server cannot confirm the mailbox.
  • Mailbox not checked: verify the address again with the Mailbox exists check selected.
  • No answer in time, Server asked to retry later, and the other reasons of a Not verifiable result: verify the address again later; the checks left without an answer were refunded.

The whole method, from export to a staged send, is in How to clean an email list.

See every check

Click View details on a result, or a row of the Verifications history, to open Verification detail. It shows the verdict, the score, the recommendation, and the cause, then, under Checks, the outcome of each check: OK, Flagged, Problem, No answer, or Skipped.

Questions

Why is an Outlook mailbox never confirmed?

Outlook and Yahoo answer every check the same way, so no one can confirm a mailbox there. Gmail and Google Workspace do say whether a mailbox exists, so an address there comes back confirmed or rejected like any other. The address leads to a real provider, so it comes back Valid and Send, with the reason shown and a score kept below that of a confirmed mailbox.

Should I remove every address a check flagged?

Not necessarily. Risky means a check raised a flag; the recommendation tells you whether to review the address or to remove it.

Do I pay when the mail server gives no answer?

Only for the checks that answered, such as the address format and the domain. The mailbox check and the catch-all check, left without an answer, are refunded: see Tokens and plans.

  • Verify your first address

    Create your PricklyMails account, confirm it with the code we email you, then verify a first address in the dashboard and read the answer it gives.

  • Verify a whole list

    Verify a list in one batch: upload or paste it, follow its progress, read and download the report, and see what happens to duplicates and invalid lines.

  • Tokens and plans

    How billing works: tokens spent check by check, what each check costs, plans and top-ups, tokens that never expire, and what is refunded or never billed.

  • Keep your account secure

    Set a strong password, turn on two-factor authentication, sign out the devices you do not recognize, and know which security emails your account sends you.

  • Create and manage API keys

    Create an API key for a tool or a script, choose a live or a test key and the checks it runs, then revoke it the moment the tool no longer needs it.

  • Connect an AI assistant

    Let Claude, ChatGPT, Cursor or another MCP client verify addresses for you: create an agent, add the PricklyMails server, approve it, and revoke it anytime.

  • Your data and how long we keep it

    What happens to the addresses you verify, what the shared cache and your own browser keep, and what remains once you delete your account, and for how long.

Check your list before your next send.

1,000 tokens free when you sign up, no credit card. After that, you only pay for answers.