The 10 tokens cover address format, domain, mailbox, disposable address, generic address, and free mailbox; catch-all detection adds 4 tokens and comes with the Pro plan and above.
PricklyMails vs Captain Verify
PricklyMails and Captain Verify compared on pricing, free credits, credit expiry, unknown and catch-all results, data retention and hosting, API, and MCP.
Captain Verify: its price as its pricing page showed it on October 22, 2026. Captain Verify pricing (opens in a new tab)
Captain Verify is a French service that verifies email addresses and mobile numbers, founded in 2015 in Draguignan, in Provence, and hosted in France. If you are looking at alternatives, this comparison puts PricklyMails and Captain Verify side by side, strictly on points you can check for yourself: pricing, free credits, credit expiry, uncertain results, catch-all domains, your data, the API, and the MCP server.
The comparison at a glance
| Criterion | PricklyMails | Captain Verify |
|---|---|---|
| Pricing model | Per check, in tokens: 10 per address, 14 with catch-all detection | One credit per verification |
| Free tier | Free tokens on signup, once, no credit card | 100 credits on signup |
| Subscription | Four paid plans, each granting tokens every month | Monthly plans 10% below its pack prices, annual ones with 2 months free; a month's credits do not carry over |
| Credit expiry | Never, even after you cancel | Pack credits valid 365 days, extended by 365 days when you log in before they expire |
| Unknown results | Tests that got no answer are refunded, completed checks are billed | Credited back |
| Catch-all domains | Returned Risky, recommendation Review | Flagged "ok4all" and filed under risky, in every verification |
| Address retention | Never written to disk; a fingerprint computed with a secret key is kept with the result | Files and verifications kept 90 days by default, or 30 or 7 days if you choose |
| Hosting | Germany, in the EU | France, at OVHcloud and Scaleway |
| API | REST | REST, up to 50 checks a minute |
| MCP server for AI agents | Hosted, connected over OAuth with no key to copy | None described on its pages |
Pricing
Captain Verify bills one credit per verification, at a price per credit that falls with the volume you buy, from 1,000 to 5 million verifications. PricklyMails bills each check in tokens: address format 1, domain 2, mailbox 4, disposable address 1, generic address 1, free mailbox 1, catch-all 4. PricklyMails charges no VAT (VAT exemption for small businesses, article 293 B of the French General Tax Code); Captain Verify's prices exclude tax, and it adds VAT unless you give it a valid EU VAT number.
What a whole list costs
The table prices a whole list at each size: Captain Verify's credit pack for that many verifications, excluding tax, and the cheapest way to verify the list in one batch at PricklyMails, with a plan, a top-up, or both.
| Addresses | Captain Verify | PricklyMails |
|---|---|---|
| 1,000 | $8 | ≈ $8.99€8Starter plan |
| 10,000 | $71 | ≈ $35.95€32Pro plan |
| 100,000 | $236 | ≈ $135€120Business plan |
| 1,000,000 | $767 | ≈ $1,236€1,100Enterprise plan and a top-up |
Captain Verify: its prices as its pricing page showed them on October 22, 2026, without a subscription unless marked as a plan. Excluding tax. Captain Verify pricing (opens in a new tab)
PricklyMails: the cheapest way to verify the whole list in one batch with every check the free plan allows (address format, domain, mailbox, disposable, generic address and free mailbox), at today's prices, with no VAT. PricklyMails prices in euros, and its checkout shows the amount in your own currency, converted by Stripe: the dollar figures here are estimates at the same rate, 1.1234 dollars for one euro on October 21, 2026.
Subscriptions
Captain Verify also sells a monthly credit pack by subscription, from 5,000 to 1,000,000 verifications a month, 10% below its on-demand prices, and an annual subscription gives 2 months free. A month's credits do not carry over to the next month. A monthly subscription can be canceled at any time, effective at the end of the current month; an annual one renews automatically and is canceled with 30 days' notice before its anniversary date. PricklyMails has four paid plans, each granting tokens every month; billed annually, a plan costs 11 months for 12 months of tokens.
Credit expiry
PricklyMails tokens never expire, whether they come from a plan, a top-up, or your signup, and they stay on your balance after you cancel. At Captain Verify, credits bought in a pack are valid for 365 days from the order, and logging in to your account before they expire extends them by another 365 days. Its terms add that expired credits are neither carried over nor refunded, and that an account with no login for 2 years is deleted.
What is not billed
Captain Verify does not count unknown results or duplicates, and removes duplicates for free. At PricklyMails, duplicates within one request are not charged, an address verified recently is served again for free, and tests that got no answer are refunded.
Uncertain results
Unknown results
Captain Verify returns "unknown" when the remote server does not answer in time, and credits the verification back. When a server uses greylisting, it waits up to 30 minutes and tries again before concluding. PricklyMails refunds the tests that got no answer (the mailbox test and, when you ran it, the catch-all test) and bills the checks that completed, such as the address format and the domain. On an unknown result, Captain Verify costs you nothing; PricklyMails costs you the checks that did answer.
Gmail, Outlook, and Yahoo
PricklyMails asks Gmail and Google Workspace about each mailbox like any other server, so an address there comes back confirmed or rejected. Outlook and Yahoo do not reliably say whether a mailbox exists: for their addresses, PricklyMails returns Valid, with a capped score and the reason shown, and bills every check you asked for, mailbox test included. Captain Verify's FAQ says it verifies addresses at every major provider, Gmail, Yahoo, Hotmail, and Outlook included, and its billing rule makes no exception for them. We do not know what it returns for those addresses: its pages do not say.
Catch-all domains
On a domain that accepts every address, Captain Verify flags the address "ok4all" and files it under risky. Its guide to catch-all emails says verification then stops at the domain level, and the mailbox's validity stays open. It reports this flag in every verification, for the same single credit. PricklyMails does not settle these addresses either: the address comes back Risky, with the recommendation Review and the reason shown. Catch-all detection comes with the Pro plan and above, and adds 4 tokens. The guide on catch-all domains explains the approach we chose.
Your data
Both services keep your data in the European Union: Captain Verify in France, PricklyMails in Germany. Captain Verify keeps your files and verifications for 90 days by default, then deletes them from your account and its servers; you can shorten that period to 30 or 7 days. It hosts its services in OVHcloud and Scaleway data centers in France, and says no data is transferred outside the European Union. PricklyMails never writes the address to disk: it stays in memory until its verification ends, 96 hours at most. All that remains afterward is a fingerprint, computed with a secret key only we hold, which does not let anyone read the address back. That fingerprint is kept with the result for as long as your account exists, for your history and for the verification cache shared across customers.
What Captain Verify offers on top
- Mobile number verification (HLR lookup), by file or API, covering more than 300 operators in 96 countries.
- Free tools: an email tester for a single address, and an email permutator that lists the possible addresses for a name and a domain.
- Team members included, who share the account and its credits.
- A French company, with its site and documentation in six languages, French included.
- Hosting providers certified ISO 27001 and SOC 2, and a data protection officer.
PricklyMails focuses on verifying addresses, through the dashboard, the API, webhooks, or an AI agent.
Which one to choose
Captain Verify is the better fit if you want:
- A French company with its servers in France.
- Unknown results that cost nothing at all.
- Catch-all domains flagged in every verification, at no extra credit.
- Mobile number verification in the same account.
- Large lists at a price per credit that falls with volume: compare in the table above.
PricklyMails is the better fit if you want:
- To pay check by check.
- Tokens that never expire, where Captain Verify's pack credits last 365 days unless you log in.
- No address ever written to disk, where Captain Verify keeps files for 90 days by default.
- To connect an AI agent over OAuth, without copying a key.
- No VAT added, with or without a VAT number.
The simplest way to compare is still to try both on a few addresses from your own list: create an account and get free tokens on signup, no credit card required.
About this comparison
Accurate as of October 22, 2026. Every fact about Captain Verify comes from its own public pages, checked on that date and listed at the end of this page. Anything we could not confirm on those pages is left out. Prices and terms change, so check them at the source before you decide. Spotted something inaccurate? Write to us and we will correct it.
Note
Worth knowing: we make PricklyMails. The choice of criteria is ours; the facts are sourced.
Sources
- Packs and prices in euros, subscriptions, 100 free credits, unknown results credited back, servers in France: pricing in euros (opens in a new tab)captainverify.com
- Prices in US dollars: pricing (opens in a new tab)captainverify.com
- Credits, unknown results and duplicates not counted, credit expiry, retention, hosting, VAT, providers covered, team members: FAQ (opens in a new tab)captainverify.com
- Statuses, the ok4all flag, greylisting: email documentation (opens in a new tab)captainverify.com
- What ok4all means and why verification stops at the domain: catch-all emails explained (opens in a new tab)captainverify.com
- Pack credit validity, subscriptions and cancellation, inactive accounts, file deletion: terms and conditions (opens in a new tab)captainverify.com
- Hosting at OVHcloud and Scaleway, no transfer outside the EU, data protection officer: security (opens in a new tab)captainverify.com
- Founding year and location: about (opens in a new tab)captainverify.com
- API and its limits: email validation API (opens in a new tab)captainverify.com and file sending API (opens in a new tab)captainverify.com
- Mobile number verification: HLR lookup (opens in a new tab)captainverify.com
- Free tools: email tester (opens in a new tab)captainverify.com and email permutator (opens in a new tab)captainverify.com
For PricklyMails: the pricing section, the billing documentation, and the privacy policy.