Catch-all detection comes with the PricklyMails Pro plan and above.
PricklyMails vs Emailable
PricklyMails and Emailable compared on verifiable points: pricing, free credits, credit expiry, unknown results, catch-all, your data, API, and AI agents.
Emailable: its price as its pricing page showed it on October 22, 2026. Emailable pricing (opens in a new tab)
Emailable, headquartered in New York, is an email verification service that also sells deliverability tools. If you are looking at alternatives, this comparison puts PricklyMails and Emailable side by side, strictly on points you can check for yourself: pricing, free credits, credit expiry, uncertain results, catch-all domains, your data, the API, and AI agents.
The comparison at a glance
| Criterion | PricklyMails | Emailable |
|---|---|---|
| Pricing model | Per check, in tokens: an address costs the checks you run | One credit per verification, by list, API, or widget |
| Free tier | Free tokens on signup, once, no credit card | 250 free credits for every new account |
| Credit expiry | Never, even after you cancel | Never, and subscription credits roll over |
| Unknown results | Tests that got no answer are refunded, completed checks are billed | Not charged; on a list, credited back with duplicates once it finishes |
| Catch-all domains | Returned as Risky, with the recommendation Review | Some resolved to deliverable or undeliverable, the rest returned as "risky" |
| Address retention | Never written to disk; a fingerprint computed with a secret key is kept with the result | All data deleted 30 days after verification, API data sooner if you choose |
| Hosting | Germany, in the EU | Not stated on its pages |
| API | REST | HTTP, with libraries for Node.js, Ruby, and Python |
| Tools for AI agents | Hosted MCP server, connected over OAuth with no key to copy | A command-line tool for agents that run shell commands; no MCP server on the pages we read |
Pricing
Emailable bills one credit per verification, at a price per credit that falls with the volume you buy. Its minimum purchase is 5,000 credits, every new account starts with 250 free credits, and it prices volumes above 1,000,000 credits on request. PricklyMails bills each check in tokens: address format 1, domain 2, mailbox 4, disposable address 1, generic address 1, free mailbox 1, catch-all 4. An address costs the sum of the checks you run, and catch-all detection comes with the Pro plan and above.
Emailable's pricing page can also show its prices in euros, with the same figures, and it does not say whether they include tax. PricklyMails charges no VAT (VAT exemption for small businesses, article 293 B of the French General Tax Code).
What a whole list costs
The table prices a whole list at each size: Emailable's credit pack for that many addresses, or its smallest pack when the list is smaller, and the cheapest way to verify the list in one batch at PricklyMails, with a plan, a top-up or both.
| Addresses | Emailable | PricklyMails |
|---|---|---|
| 1,000 | $38a 5,000 pack | ≈ $8.99€8Starter plan |
| 10,000 | $60 | ≈ $35.95€32Pro plan |
| 100,000 | $420 | ≈ $135€120Business plan |
| 1,000,000 | $2,100 | ≈ $1,236€1,100Enterprise plan and a top-up |
Emailable: its prices as its pricing page showed them on October 22, 2026, without a subscription unless marked as a plan. Emailable pricing (opens in a new tab)
PricklyMails: the cheapest way to verify the whole list in one batch with every check the free plan allows (address format, domain, mailbox, disposable, generic address and free mailbox), at today's prices, with no VAT. PricklyMails prices in euros, and its checkout shows the amount in your own currency, converted by Stripe: the dollar figures here are estimates at the same rate, 1.1234 dollars for one euro on October 21, 2026.
Subscriptions
Emailable also sells its credits by subscription, 15% below its pay-as-you-go price, with no long-term commitment. Each cycle reloads your credits, and unused ones roll over. Its deliverability tools draw on the same credits: 100 credits per inbox placement report, and 5 per blacklist check. PricklyMails has four paid plans, each granting tokens every month; billed annually, a plan costs 11 months for 12 months of tokens.
Credit expiry
On this point the two are even. Emailable's credits never expire, and a subscription's unused credits carry over from one cycle to the next. PricklyMails tokens never expire either, whether they come from a plan, a top-up, or your signup, and they stay on your balance after you cancel.
What is not billed
At Emailable, credits spent on unknown results and on duplicates are returned to your balance once your list finishes verifying. At PricklyMails, duplicates within one request are not charged, an address verified recently is served again for free, and tests that got no answer are refunded.
Uncertain results
Unknown results
Emailable returns "unknown" when it could not determine with confidence whether the address is valid, and does not charge for it; on a list, the credit comes back once the list finishes verifying. PricklyMails refunds the tests that got no answer (the mailbox test and, when you ran it, the catch-all test) and bills the checks that completed, such as the address format and the domain. On an unknown result, Emailable costs you nothing; PricklyMails costs you the checks that did answer.
Gmail, Outlook, and Yahoo
PricklyMails asks Gmail and Google Workspace about each mailbox like any other server, so an address there comes back confirmed or rejected. Outlook and Yahoo do not reliably say whether a mailbox exists: for their addresses, PricklyMails returns Valid, with a capped score and the reason shown, and bills every check you asked for, mailbox test included. We do not know how Emailable answers or bills that case: its pages do not say.
Catch-all domains
On a domain that accepts every address, Emailable says it resolves some addresses to deliverable or undeliverable, and returns the rest as "risky" (accept-all). Through its API, the accept-all check is off unless you ask for it, since it slows the response. PricklyMails does not settle these addresses: the address comes back Risky, with the recommendation Review and the reason shown. Catch-all detection comes with the Pro plan and above. The guide on catch-all domains explains the approach we chose.
Your data
Emailable permanently deletes all verification data 30 days after verification, and lets you choose how long API single and batch verification data is kept within that limit. Its pages we read do not say where it stores verification data; its privacy policy bases transfers of personal data from the EU to the United States on the EU-U.S. Data Privacy Framework. PricklyMails, hosted in Germany, never writes the address to disk: it stays in memory until its verification ends, 96 hours at most. All that remains afterward is a fingerprint, computed with a secret key only we hold, which does not let anyone read the address back. That fingerprint is kept with the result for as long as your account exists, for your history and for the verification cache shared across customers.
AI agents
Emailable offers a free, open-source command-line tool for agents that can run shell commands, and sets it up for Claude Code, Codex, and OpenCode; you sign in through your browser or with an API key. PricklyMails runs a hosted MCP server, connected over OAuth with no key to copy, which a chat assistant reaches without running commands on your machine.
What Emailable offers on top
- Deliverability tools: inbox placement reports, blacklist monitoring, and detection of DMARC, SPF, and DKIM errors.
- Enrichment: the SMTP provider, a first and last name, a gender, and a birth year for each address, plus a quality score from 0 to 100.
- A deliverability guarantee: Emailable guarantees 99% deliverability or more on the addresses it marks deliverable, 97% or more for addresses managed by Microsoft, and refunds qualifying addresses, under conditions.
- A form widget, integrations with more than 50 apps, and payment by PayPal, Apple Pay, or Google Pay.
- SOC 2 Type II: its pricing page states the certification.
PricklyMails focuses on verifying addresses, through the dashboard, the API, webhooks, or an AI agent.
Which one to choose
Emailable is the better fit if you want:
- Unknown results and duplicates credited back in full.
- A decision on more of your catch-all addresses.
- Deliverability tools and enrichment in the same account.
- A subscription 15% below pay-as-you-go, with credits that roll over.
- Large lists at a price per credit that falls with volume.
PricklyMails is the better fit if you want:
- To pay check by check.
- A small purchase: Emailable sells at least 5,000 credits at a time, and the table shows what a list of 1,000 costs at each.
- No address ever written to disk, on servers in the EU.
- A hosted MCP server over OAuth, for an assistant that does not run shell commands.
The simplest way to compare is still to try both on a few addresses from your own list: create an account and get free tokens on signup, no credit card required.
About this comparison
Accurate as of October 22, 2026. Every fact about Emailable comes from its own public pages, checked on that date and listed at the end of this comparison. Anything we could not confirm on those pages is left out or marked as not stated. Prices and terms change, so check them at the source before you decide. Spotted something inaccurate? Write to us and we will correct it.
Note
Worth knowing: we make PricklyMails. The choice of criteria is ours; the facts are sourced.
Sources
- Packs and prices, minimum purchase, 250 free credits, credits that never expire, unknown results and duplicates refunded, subscriptions, deliverability credits, payment methods, SOC 2 Type II: emailable.com/pricing (opens in a new tab)emailable.com
- Credit rules, unknown results and duplicates not charged, subscription cycles: how credits work (opens in a new tab)emailable.com
- Returned states, including "risky" and "unknown": all possible states and reasons (opens in a new tab)emailable.com
- Catch-all handling: understand accept-all verification (opens in a new tab)emailable.com
- Accept-all check in the API: API emails reference (opens in a new tab)emailable.com
- Deletion after 30 days, API retention settings: data retention (opens in a new tab)emailable.com
- Transfers to the United States: privacy policy (opens in a new tab)emailable.com
- Command-line tool for AI agents: emailable.com/agents (opens in a new tab)emailable.com
- Deliverability guarantee: our guarantee (opens in a new tab)emailable.com
- Deliverability tools, enrichment, quality score, libraries, integrations: emailable.com (opens in a new tab)emailable.com
- Headquarters: about us (opens in a new tab)emailable.com
For PricklyMails: the pricing section, the billing documentation, and the privacy policy.