Catch-all detection comes with the PricklyMails Pro plan and above. Verifalia's quality levels differ in how many times the engine retries a test and how long it waits for a slow server.
PricklyMails vs Verifalia
PricklyMails and Verifalia compared on verifiable points: pricing model, free tier, credit expiry, unknown results, catch-all, data retention, hosting, API, and MCP.
Verifalia: its price as its pricing page showed it on October 22, 2026. Verifalia pricing (opens in a new tab)
Verifalia is an email verification service made by Cobisi Research, a company founded in 2005 and based in Italy. If you are looking at alternatives, this comparison puts PricklyMails and Verifalia side by side, strictly on points you can check for yourself: pricing, free tier, credit expiry, uncertain results, catch-all domains, your data, the API, and the MCP server.
The comparison at a glance
| Criterion | PricklyMails | Verifalia |
|---|---|---|
| Pricing model | Per check, in tokens: 10 per address without catch-all, 14 with it | One credit per address at the Standard quality level, 2 at High, 4 at Extreme |
| Free tier | Tokens on signup, once, no credit card | 25 credits a day on the Free plan |
| Credit expiry | Never, even after you cancel | Never for credit packs; a plan's daily credits expire at the end of each day |
| Unknown results | Tests that got no answer are refunded, completed checks are billed | Not stated on its pages |
| Catch-all domains | Returned as Risky, with the recommendation Review | Returned with the status ServerIsCatchAll, described as possibly risky |
| Address retention | Never written to disk; a fingerprint computed with a secret key is kept with the result | Never written to a persistent medium, it says; lists deleted after a period you set, from 5 minutes to 30 days |
| Hosting | Germany, in the EU | Germany, per its privacy policy |
| API | REST | REST, with open-source SDKs |
| MCP server for AI agents | Hosted, connected over OAuth with no key to copy | None found on its pages |
Pricing
Verifalia bills one credit per address at its Standard quality level, 2 credits at High, and 4 at Extreme. PricklyMails bills each check in tokens: address format 1, domain 2, mailbox 4, disposable address 1, generic address 1, free mailbox 1, catch-all 4. Every check but catch-all comes to 10 tokens per address; catch-all adds 4, on the Pro plan and above.
PricklyMails charges no VAT (VAT exemption for small businesses, article 293 B of the French General Tax Code). Verifalia adds VAT for private individuals in the EU and for EU companies without a VAT ID, and adds 22% VAT for every client in Italy, where it is based.
What a whole list costs
The table prices a whole list at each size: Verifalia's credit pack for that many addresses, at the Standard quality level, and the cheapest way to verify the list in one batch at PricklyMails, with a plan, a top-up or both.
| Addresses | Verifalia | PricklyMails |
|---|---|---|
| 1,000 | $7.90 | ≈ $8.99€8Starter plan |
| 10,000 | $49.90 | ≈ $35.95€32Pro plan |
| 100,000 | $389 | ≈ $135€120Business plan |
| 1,000,000 | $1,490 | ≈ $1,236€1,100Enterprise plan and a top-up |
Verifalia: its prices as its pricing page showed them on October 22, 2026, without a subscription unless marked as a plan. Verifalia pricing (opens in a new tab)
PricklyMails: the cheapest way to verify the whole list in one batch with every check the free plan allows (address format, domain, mailbox, disposable, generic address and free mailbox), at today's prices, with no VAT. PricklyMails prices in euros, and its checkout shows the amount in your own currency, converted by Stripe: the dollar figures here are estimates at the same rate, 1.1234 dollars for one euro on October 21, 2026.
Verifalia's pricing page lists packs from 1,000 to 10,000,000 credits, and its help center says packs start at 500; the price per credit falls as the pack grows. At the High or Extreme quality level, the same pack covers half or a quarter as many addresses. PricklyMails sells tokens in any quantity, with no pack sizes, at a price per token that also falls as the top-up grows.
Subscriptions
Verifalia's plans grant credits every day rather than every month, and credit packs cover what goes beyond them.
| Plan | Monthly price | Credits per day |
|---|---|---|
| Free | $0 | 25 |
| Starter | $9 | 250 |
| Professional | $49 | 1,250 |
| Enterprise | $199 | 6,250 |
| Ultimate | $499 | 25,000 |
Verifalia: prices in US dollars, billed monthly, as its pricing page showed them on October 22, 2026; quarterly billing saves 5% and yearly billing 10%. A plan's daily credits are spent first, then the credits of your packs.
Verifalia does not refund the unused part of a plan, and bills an upgrade pro rata for the rest of the billing cycle. PricklyMails has four paid plans, each granting tokens every month; billed annually, a plan costs 11 months for 12 months of tokens.
Credit expiry
PricklyMails tokens never expire, whether they come from a plan, a top-up, or your signup, and they stay on your balance after you cancel. At Verifalia, credits bought in a pack never expire. A plan's daily credits do not accumulate: those left unused expire at midnight GMT, and the plan grants new ones for the next day.
What is not billed
At Verifalia, an address that appears twice in a list is marked as a duplicate, and duplicates cost no credit. At PricklyMails, duplicates within one request are not charged, an address verified recently is served again for free, and tests that got no answer are refunded.
Uncertain results
Unknown results
Verifalia classifies every result as deliverable, risky, undeliverable, or unknown. The pages we read do not say whether a result its engine could not settle costs a credit. For a timeout, a greylisting server, or a mailbox that is temporarily unavailable, its status descriptions suggest running the address again at a higher quality level, which costs 2 or 4 credits. PricklyMails refunds the tests that got no answer (the mailbox test and, when you ran it, the catch-all test) and bills the checks that completed, such as the address format and the domain.
Gmail, Outlook, and Yahoo
PricklyMails asks Gmail and Google Workspace about each mailbox like any other server, so an address there comes back confirmed or rejected. Outlook and Yahoo do not reliably say whether a mailbox exists: for their addresses, PricklyMails returns Valid, with a capped score and the reason shown, and bills every check you asked for, mailbox test included. Verifalia says its validator can check even the most challenging mail exchangers, Yahoo included; its pages do not say how it bills these addresses.
Catch-all domains
On a domain that accepts every address, Verifalia returns the status ServerIsCatchAll: it describes the address as possibly risky, since the existence of the mailbox cannot be verified.
On its paid plans, override rules let you classify matching addresses your own way, from 5 rules on Starter to 100 on Ultimate.
PricklyMails does not resolve them: the address comes back Risky, with the recommendation Review and the reason shown.
Catch-all detection comes with the Pro plan and above.
The guide on catch-all domains explains the approach we chose.
Your data
Both services say they keep verified addresses off disk, and both store data in Germany. Verifalia says it never stores the addresses it verifies on any persistent medium, and keeps personal data in RAM. It deletes a list once the retention period you set is over, from 5 minutes to 30 days after the list finishes, and you can delete it sooner from its client area or its API. PricklyMails never writes the address to disk: it stays in memory until its verification ends, 96 hours at most. All that remains afterward is a fingerprint, computed with a secret key only we hold, which does not let anyone read the address back. That fingerprint is kept with the result for as long as your account exists, for your history and for the verification cache shared across customers. The difference is what stays: at Verifalia, the list, until the period you chose ends; at PricklyMails, a fingerprint with each result.
What Verifalia offers on top
Verifalia's High and Extreme quality levels retry each test more times and wait longer for slow servers, at 2 or 4 credits per address. It offers an embeddable JavaScript widget that checks addresses as people type them into a form, open-source SDKs for .NET, Go, Java, JavaScript, PHP, and Ruby, a Google Sheets add-on, and integrations through Zapier and Pipedream. On the account side, it offers users and browser apps with their own permissions, sign-in with X.509 client certificates, and reselling. PricklyMails focuses on verifying addresses, through the dashboard, the API, webhooks, or an AI agent.
Which one to choose
Verifalia is the better fit if you want:
- Higher quality levels that retry the tests and wait longer for slow servers.
- A retention period you set yourself, down to 5 minutes.
- Daily credits for a steady flow of new addresses.
- Ready-made SDKs and a form widget.
- Prices in your own currency, among 21.
PricklyMails is the better fit if you want:
- To pay check by check.
- Tokens that never expire, those from a plan included.
- No VAT on top of the price.
- To connect an AI agent over OAuth, without copying a key.
The simplest way to compare is still to try both on a few addresses from your own list: create an account and get free tokens on signup, no credit card required.
About this comparison
Accurate as of October 22, 2026. Every fact about Verifalia comes from its own public pages, checked on that date and listed at the end of this page. Anything we could not confirm on those pages is left out. Prices and terms change, so check them at the source before you decide. Spotted something inaccurate? Write to us and we will correct it.
Note
Worth knowing: we make PricklyMails. The choice of criteria is ours; the facts are sourced.
Sources
- Cobisi Research, founded in 2005 and based in Italy: about Verifalia (opens in a new tab)verifalia.com
- Credit packs, plans, daily credits, override rules, data kept in RAM, configurable retention, currencies: verifalia.com/pricing (opens in a new tab)verifalia.com
- Daily credits expiring at midnight, spent before pack credits: how daily free credits work (opens in a new tab)verifalia.com
- Packs from 500 credits: what credit packs include (opens in a new tab)verifalia.com
- VAT: are prices subject to VAT (opens in a new tab)verifalia.com
- Quality levels and their credits: result quality levels (opens in a new tab)verifalia.com
- Classifications and statuses, including
ServerIsCatchAllandDuplicate: status codes (opens in a new tab)verifalia.com - Data deleted after the retention period: email verification API (opens in a new tab)verifalia.com
- Data stored in Germany: privacy policy (opens in a new tab)verifalia.com
- Yahoo and challenging mail exchangers: free email validator (opens in a new tab)verifalia.com
- REST API and SDKs: developers (opens in a new tab)verifalia.com
- Zapier and Pipedream: integrations (opens in a new tab)verifalia.com
For PricklyMails: the pricing section, the billing documentation, the MCP documentation, and the privacy policy.
