Catch-all detection comes with the PricklyMails Pro plan and above.
PricklyMails vs MailerCheck
PricklyMails and MailerCheck compared on verifiable points: pricing model, free tier, credit expiry, unknown results, catch-all, data and hosting, API, and MCP.
MailerCheck: its price as its pricing page showed it on October 22, 2026. MailerCheck pricing (opens in a new tab)
MailerCheck is an email verification service created by the team behind MailerLite. If you are looking at alternatives, this comparison puts PricklyMails and MailerCheck side by side, strictly on points you can check for yourself: pricing, free tier, credit expiry, uncertain results, catch-all domains, your data, the API, and the MCP server.
The comparison at a glance
| Criterion | PricklyMails | MailerCheck |
|---|---|---|
| Pricing model | Per check, in tokens: 10 per address without catch-all, 14 with it | One credit per address verified |
| Free tier | Tokens on signup, once, no credit card | 10 credits on signup, no credit card |
| Credit expiry | Never, even after you cancel | Never |
| Unknown results | Tests that got no answer are refunded, completed checks are billed | Not charged |
| Catch-all domains | Returned as Risky, with the recommendation Review | Returned with the status "catch-all" |
| Address retention | Never written to disk; a fingerprint computed with a secret key is kept with the result | No period stated for uploaded lists |
| Hosting | Germany, in the EU | Its pages differ: the EU, or South Carolina in the US |
| API | REST | REST |
| MCP server for AI agents | Hosted, connected over OAuth with no key to copy | None found on its pages |
Pricing
MailerCheck bills one credit per address verified, at a price per credit that falls with the volume you buy, with a minimum purchase of 1,000 credits. PricklyMails bills each check in tokens: address format 1, domain 2, mailbox 4, disposable address 1, generic address 1, free mailbox 1, catch-all 4. Every check but catch-all comes to 10 tokens per address; catch-all adds 4, on the Pro plan and above.
PricklyMails charges no VAT (VAT exemption for small businesses, article 293 B of the French General Tax Code); MailerCheck says taxes may apply.
What a whole list costs
The table prices a whole list at each size: MailerCheck's price for that many credits, and the cheapest way to verify the list in one batch at PricklyMails, with a plan, a top-up or both.
| Addresses | MailerCheck | PricklyMails |
|---|---|---|
| 1,000 | $10 | ≈ $8.99€8Starter plan |
| 10,000 | $80 | ≈ $35.95€32Pro plan |
| 100,000 | $500 | ≈ $135€120Business plan |
| 1,000,000 | $2,000 | ≈ $1,236€1,100Enterprise plan and a top-up |
MailerCheck: its prices as its pricing page showed them on October 22, 2026, without a subscription unless marked as a plan. MailerCheck pricing (opens in a new tab)
PricklyMails: the cheapest way to verify the whole list in one batch with every check the free plan allows (address format, domain, mailbox, disposable, generic address and free mailbox), at today's prices, with no VAT. PricklyMails prices in euros, and its checkout shows the amount in your own currency, converted by Stripe: the dollar figures here are estimates at the same rate, 1.1234 dollars for one euro on October 21, 2026.
MailerCheck's pricing page goes from 1,000 to 5,000,000 credits, and its help center says you can pick one of its packages or type the number of credits you need. PricklyMails sells tokens in any quantity, with no pack sizes, at a price per token that also falls as the top-up grows.
Subscriptions
MailerCheck's pricing page lists no plan: you buy credits once, or turn on autopay, which buys the amount you chose each time your balance falls below a threshold you set. It offers no discount beyond the lower price per credit of a larger purchase. PricklyMails has four paid plans, each granting tokens every month; billed annually, a plan costs 11 months for 12 months of tokens.
Credit expiry
MailerCheck credits never expire. Its refund policy binds it to a refund only if it stops providing its service to you without cause; it may grant other refunds under its own guidelines. PricklyMails tokens never expire either, whether they come from a plan, a top-up, or your signup, and they stay on your balance after you cancel.
What is not billed
At MailerCheck, an unknown result costs no credit: the credits come back to your balance, and the credit history lists them. At PricklyMails, duplicates within one request are not charged, an address verified recently is served again for free, and tests that got no answer are refunded.
Uncertain results
Unknown results
MailerCheck does not charge for an "unknown" result: it says it charges credits only for the addresses it can verify. PricklyMails refunds the tests that got no answer (the mailbox test and, when you ran it, the catch-all test) and bills the checks that completed, such as the address format and the domain. On an unknown result, MailerCheck costs you nothing; PricklyMails costs you the checks that did answer.
Gmail, Outlook, and Yahoo
PricklyMails asks Gmail and Google Workspace about each mailbox like any other server, so an address there comes back confirmed or rejected. Outlook and Yahoo do not reliably say whether a mailbox exists: for their addresses, PricklyMails returns Valid, with a capped score and the reason shown, and bills every check you asked for, mailbox test included. We do not know how MailerCheck handles or bills that case: its pages do not say.
Catch-all domains
On a domain that accepts every address, MailerCheck returns the status "catch-all": the server will accept the email, but MailerCheck says it cannot guarantee that the address belongs to a person. Its pages do not say whether a catch-all result costs a credit. PricklyMails does not resolve them either: the address comes back Risky, with the recommendation Review and the reason shown. Catch-all detection comes with the Pro plan and above. The guide on catch-all domains explains the approach we chose.
Your data
MailerCheck's pages differ on where your data is stored. Its privacy policy says its data storage centers are in the European Union. Its security statement says its services are hosted by a "certified European data storage center" located in South Carolina, in the United States, and its data processing addendum names a Google data center in South Carolina too. That addendum also says MailerCheck may process customer data in the United States and anywhere its sub-processors operate. Its pages do not say how long uploaded lists and their results are kept: the addendum says it deletes customer data on written request once the contract ends, and the privacy policy says a deletion request takes effect within 30 days. Its API lets you delete a list yourself. PricklyMails is hosted in Germany and never writes the address to disk: it stays in memory until its verification ends, 96 hours at most. All that remains afterward is a fingerprint, computed with a secret key only we hold, which does not let anyone read the address back. That fingerprint is kept with the result for as long as your account exists, for your history and for the verification cache shared across customers.
What MailerCheck offers on top
MailerCheck sells two other tests on the same credits, 200 credits each. Email Insights analyzes an email before you send it: spam filters, HTML, spam-like words, links and images, sender authentication, and IP blocklists. Inbox Placement checks whether an email reaches the inbox or the spam folder at Gmail, AOL, Yahoo, GMX, Mail.com, and Zoho. It connects directly to MailerLite, Mailchimp, ActiveCampaign, GetResponse, and ConvertKit, and through Zapier and Make. PricklyMails focuses on verifying addresses, through the dashboard, the API, webhooks, or an AI agent.
Which one to choose
MailerCheck is the better fit if you want:
- Unknown results that cost nothing at all.
- Content and inbox placement tests paid from the same credits.
- A direct link to MailerLite and other email marketing tools.
PricklyMails is the better fit if you want:
- To pay check by check.
- A monthly plan if you verify every month.
- Your data hosted in Germany.
- No address ever written to disk.
- To connect an AI agent over OAuth, without copying a key.
The simplest way to compare is still to try both on a few addresses from your own list: create an account and get free tokens on signup, no credit card required.
About this comparison
Accurate as of October 22, 2026. Every fact about MailerCheck comes from its own public pages, checked on that date and listed at the end of this page. Anything we could not confirm on those pages is left out. Prices and terms change, so check them at the source before you decide. Spotted something inaccurate? Write to us and we will correct it.
Note
Worth knowing: we make PricklyMails. The choice of criteria is ours; the facts are sourced.
Sources
- Credits from 1,000 to 5,000,000, minimum purchase, free credits, credit expiry, discounts, refunds, taxes, Email Insights and Inbox Placement in credits: mailercheck.com/pricing (opens in a new tab)www.mailercheck.com
- One-time purchases, packages or a typed amount, autopay, credits returned for unknown results: credits and autopay (opens in a new tab)www.mailercheck.com
- Unknown results not charged: list verification (opens in a new tab)www.mailercheck.com
- Returned statuses, including "catch-all" and "unknown": statuses (opens in a new tab)www.mailercheck.com
- Refunds: about the refund policy (opens in a new tab)www.mailercheck.com
- Storage in the EU, retention and deletion: privacy policy (opens in a new tab)www.mailercheck.com
- Data center in South Carolina: security statement (opens in a new tab)www.mailercheck.com
- Google data center, processing in the US, deletion on request: data processing addendum (opens in a new tab)www.mailercheck.com
- Email Insights: mailercheck.com/features/email-insights (opens in a new tab)www.mailercheck.com
- Inbox Placement: mailercheck.com/features/inbox-placement (opens in a new tab)www.mailercheck.com
- Integrations: integrations (opens in a new tab)www.mailercheck.com
- Created by MailerLite: about (opens in a new tab)www.mailercheck.com
- REST API: API documentation (opens in a new tab)developers.mailercheck.com
- Deleting a list: email verification API (opens in a new tab)developers.mailercheck.com
For PricklyMails: the pricing section, the billing documentation, the MCP documentation, and the privacy policy.